Tuesday, February 28, 2012

Emission Standards how far will they go


There are many issues that face Mechanical Engineers and society today. The issue of combustion engines and emissions is an issue that Mechanical Engineers look at every day. Let’s take a look at diesel engines in particular.

Diesel engines have been known for producing exhaust containing fine particles that can cause short term dizziness, nausea, and coughing.  Diesel engines have also been known to cause long term conditions such as cardiovascular disease, cardiopulmonary disease, and lung cancer.  So what does society do; get rid of diesel engines and set back multiple industries that rely on diesel engines?

Instead of getting rid of diesel engines society has chosen to place emission standards on engines to clean up the exhaust fumes produced by these engines. This has caused Mechanical Engineers to take a close look at the designs of diesel engines and the exhaust fumes produced by these engines.

Engineers have made changes to the diesel engines to reduce the “black smoke” produced from diesel engines at full power when pulling a load and at start up conditions.  The restrictions placed on diesel engines emissions have forced the diesel engine industry to look to alternatives such as biodiesels and the use of catalytic converters, and changing the refining process.

The refining process has been changed to remove the sulfur content from diesel fuels before they are ever burned in a diesel engine. This change removed the strong odor that was associated with diesel fuel in the past.

Catalytic converters have cleaned up some of the harmful particles from the exhaust. The function of the catalytic converter is to convert these harmful chemicals into less noxious substances. The strict standards of today have made the catalytic converter inefficient in meeting the emission standards and more steps have become necessary.

Biodiesels help meet emission requirements because they burn cleaner but are not sufficient enough to help diesel engines meet the requirements along with catalytic converters and the renewed refining process.

As emission standards continue to become stricter and force diesel engines to become more efficient how diesel engines will meet those standards becomes a big issue. Diesel engine designers need the funding to research new technologies for limiting exhaust gases while maintaining efficiency and performance of diesel engines.

Many companies are now leaning toward Precombustion Chamber (PCC), Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) Technology and Injection Timing Retard Technology (ITR) to help meet the emission standards of today and tomorrow.

The issue of emission regulations is a constantly changing issue that causes a problem for diesel engine manufacturers and the industry that relies on the use of diesel engines.  Where does society draw the line on emission regulations?  If society continues on this strict emission regulation path how long will it be before industry is looking for a replacement for the diesel engine because they can’t meet the emission requirements. While engine emissions need to be regulated there has to be a standard time limit that allows engine designers and manufactures the time to produce the technologies needed to meet these requirements.  There also needs to be sufficient funding for research to meet these emission standards of the future if society wants to continue to use diesel engines for agricultural equipment and construction equipment.


6 comments:

  1. I really like this blog post. I thought it gave me a lot of information and I was not aware of this being a problem.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The category a diesel engine falls under (locomotive, non-road, heavy-duty truck, ect.) decides what regulation it must meet. I do agree that time is needed for manufactures to meet the requirements but aren't the specifics decided way in advance? The last time the regulations were restructured were in 2007-2008 and at that time they said in 2012 we want all engines on par with the best engine of 2007. This gave companies 5 years to meet the requirements - which could be drastic - but the previous emission standards were extremely loose. Does this "crunch" on diesel engines almost force us to advance diesel technology? Look at bio-diesel for example. One of the benefits of diesel engines is their ability to burn carbon neutral fuels without modification. The problem with internal combustion engines and global warming is not the fact that they put out CO2, but where they get their carbon from. When we burn petroleum, we are taking carbon that was trapped underground as coal and oil and putting it into the air, increasing the total amount of CO2 in the atmosphere. Fuels like plant oils do not have this problem. Plants pull their carbon from the atmosphere in the first place, so burning plant oils returns carbon to the atmosphere that was there in the first place. This brings the net carbon added to the atmosphere to (near) zero.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Dane I agree that time is given to manufacturers to meet the set requirements but right now emission standards are set to change every four years I believe but manufacturers can't afford to change their engines every four years to meet standards as it makes customers uncomfortable with engine quality. With the standards we are forced to advance diesel technology but the rate at which this must happen needs to be equated to the funding available for the research.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Nice article. I did know about the emission regulations, but I was not aware that manufacturers had a full 5 years to bring their engine up to standard, something that already existed in 2007 in a few engines.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Dane, that is an interesting point you raise about the carbon change from burning bio-diesels being almost zero. I hadn't thought about bio-diesels in that light, and it makes a strong argument for it as an alternative for fossil fuels. As for the engines themselves, its been said that necessity is the mother of invention, so if we are continually being pushed, we will need to find a way to either make the diesel engine better, or find a new alternative.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I really like when people write about pollution related topics. I think that you made good points and your blog had a lot of useful information in it.

    ReplyDelete